Soooo....Mass Effect 3

[Taelas]

Also, I completely disagree about seperating yourself from the character is roleplay. Roleplay is putting yourself into the position of the character and thinking as the character would think and doing as the character would do, that is the heart of roleplay. To just blindly choose an option because it's "paragon" or "renegade" is not roleplay at all. Roleplay requires you to think how the character would act given the situation, not because you get points one way or another.

Yes, you are putting yourself into the role of a character, but you must still have a filter between what you would do, as yourself, and what the character would do.

I didn't say you should 'blindly choose' anything. If a Paragon option is inappropriate for my Shepard, I would avoid it. It hasn't happened, but the possibility exists.

I don't think we are really disagreeing, here.