10-21-2013, 08:49 PM
(10-21-2013, 04:18 AM)Jester Wrote: If you have money in your bank account, that's wealth. If you have money in a small business, that's also wealth. Spending your bank account on a business is not changing your net wealth.It would need to also factor in your liabilities. If I borrow a million, and invest it in a new venture, then effectively I'm zero. If my new venture becomes worth 5 million, then I'm 4 million in the positive, and that wealth should be taxed at a very low rate.
(10-21-2013, 04:18 AM)DeeBye Wrote:Being a Creditor is a risk. If you can't afford to lose your money don't take risks with it, like borrowing it to someone who won't pay you back. This is no different.(10-20-2013, 01:23 PM)kandrathe Wrote: If one persons net worth is low, say due to starting a small business, then their effective tax rate is small. This strategy supports entrepreneurship.One part of this needs to be addressed. The overwhelming majority of new business ventures fail within a year, and the new business owners become bankrupt. Creditors have to eat those losses, and those losses get passed to others down the chain.
Quote:Then everyone remains poorer, and it was a bad investment. No profits, no income, no taxes.(10-20-2013, 01:23 PM)kandrathe Wrote: Once their risk has paid off and the value of the asset grows, the tax grows.And what happens when their risk doesn't pay off?