My Thoughts & What I Need

[Phoenix]

That is what I meant, the five day respawn.  So, even in a "dedicated" guild you might be able to do Onyxia 4 x per month at 2-4 scales ~ 12 /month.  So to get 40 or so, would take 4-6 months depending on the number of people.  I am assuming that we would need more than 40 people, due to real life conflicts.  So, yes, if the Lurkers hit Onyxia once per month rather than 3-4 times per month then it would take 1.5 years or longer.
[right][snapback]77330[/snapback][/right]

That's all true, so this is kind of a useless post, but anyway:

I don't think it would be that much harder to kill Onyxia 6 times a month rather than 4, so in 3 months you can have ~54 scales, which should be enough to reliably make 40-people groups, all with cloaks.